The 6 Best Biscuit Cutters, According to a Baking Expert

 

If you want to learn how to bake biscuits like a pro, you’ve come to the right place. As a culinary expert, Meggan has baked TONS of perfectly golden brown, flaky, and oh-so-delicious biscuits. She says her 5-ingredient Homemade Biscuits are easy peasy, especially because they only take 20 minutes to bake! You just have to set yourself up for success by using one of the best biscuit cutters.

Whether you’re craving light and airy Buttermilk Biscuits or want to sink your fork into a plate of rich and creamy Biscuits and Gravy, it’s important to get the right biscuit cutter or your baking adventure will (literally) fall flat. 

To help you find the right one, Meggan and I started with which biscuit cutter set she personally uses (this one from Ateco!). From there, we researched other crowd favorites from brands like Wilton, Norpro, and even snuck in a bone-shaped one for homemade dog biscuits. 

Read on to learn about brunch’s new best buddy, the biscuit cutter. 

Our Top Picks: 

1. What’s In Meggan’s Kitchen: Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters – $24.99 at Amazon
2. Also Great: Hulisen Biscuit Cutter Set – $11.19 at Amazon
3. Best Plastic Biscuit Cutters: Wilton Double Sided Circle Cookie Cutter Set – $15.75 at Michaels
4. Best Biscuit Cutters with Handles: Norpro Biscuit/Cookie Cutters – $8.10 at Amazon
5. Best Double Sided Biscuit Cutters: SurgeHai Double Sided Biscuit Cutters – $9.59 at Amazon
6. Best for Dog Biscuits: Dog Bone Biscuit and Cookie Cutters – $15.99 at Amazon

Reviews of The Best Biscuit Cutters

1. What’s In Meggan’s Kitchen: Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters

Crafted from durable stainless steel, this set of round biscuit cutters has proven itself as a must-have for any biscuit baker. Meggan loves them so much she’s bought 3 of them! Each set has 11 different sizes that range from ¾ to 3 5/8-inches, allowing you to customize the size of your biscuits or use them for a variety of other kitchen tasks.

“I love having a set so I have options for different biscuit sizes. I can use the cutters for cookies, donuts, fruit, vegetables, or other food items,” Meggan says. “My favorite feature is that they all nestle together in a cute little tin, which keeps them organized when tucked into a drawer.”

The cutters have a plain, sharp edge that cleanly slices through stickier doughs without squishing it down. This helps ensure that the dough will rise and results in fluffier biscuits! The top end of each one also has a rolled edge for an easier grip and, because they’re stainless steel, they’re rust-resistant and can be popped in the dishwasher for easy cleaning. 

The Specs:

• Material: Stainless steel
• Number of Pieces: 11 (plus tin)
• Dishwasher Safe: Yes

What I Like:

• Variety of sizes
• Easy to store
• Sturdy
• Easy to clean

What I Don’t Like:

• The steel is a bit thin

What Others Are Saying:

The Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters has a 4.6-star rating from more than 3,800 reviews on Amazon. Additionally, America’s Test Kitchen named this set the best biscuit cutters.

Buy the Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters:

2. Also Great: Hulisen Biscuit Cutter Set

The set includes five different sizes of biscuit cutters, offering flexibility in creating biscuits of various diameters. The best thing about them is the ergonomic handle that’s comfortable to hold and easy to push down. (It’s especially nice if you have dexterity issues!) Even though each cutter nests inside one other, the handles do make them harder to store, so you’ll want to make sure you have enough space for them. 

We love that they maintain a sharp rim all the way around so you can punch straight through the dough. They also have handy and clearly marked measurements on the side for early mornings when the coffee hasn’t kicked in yet. 

Like other quality biscuit sets we recommend, the high-grade stainless steel is rust-proof, easy to clean, and dishwasher-safe, so you’re sure to have these biscuit cutters for a long time. 

The Specs:

• Material: Stainless Steel
• Number of Pieces: 5
• Dishwasher Safe: Yes

What I Like:

• The handles are ergonomic
• Measurements are clearly marked
• Sharp edges
• Variety of sizes

What I Don’t Like:

• Handles make them tough to store
• Some think the handle gets in the way

What Others Are Saying:

The Hulisen Biscuit Cutter Set has a 4.8-star rating from more than 13,200 ratings on Amazon. It was also featured by All Recipes as a tool for perfect biscuits.  

Buy the Hulisen Biscuit Cutter Set:

3. Best Plastic Biscuit Cutters: Wilton Double Sided Circle Cookie Cutter Set

If you have little helpers in the kitchen, a plastic set like this one might be a better way to go. While plastic may not offer the same durability as stainless steel, they also don’t have sharp edges that can cut up your fingers while riffling around your kitchen drawers or rushing to empty the dishwasher. 

These biscuit cutters are lightweight yet sturdy, making them easy to handle. The different colors are nice so you can know at a glance which size you are pulling out, plus they’re double sized — one side is scalloped and the other flat, offering tons of versatility in the kitchen.

The smooth, rounded edges of these cutters ensure clean and precise cuts, resulting in beautifully shaped baked goods every time. Additionally, the plastic material is easy to clean and is still dishwasher safe. They also nestle inside each other, making them ideal for those with limited storage areas or smaller kitchens.

The Specs:

• Material: Plastic
• Number of Pieces: 6
• Dishwasher Safe: Yes

What I Like:

• Versatile double-sided design
• Lightweight
• Easy to handle
• Compact design for easy storage

What I Don’t Like:

• Plastic is not as durable as stainless steel

Buy the Wilton Double Sided Circle Cookie Cutter Set:

4. Best Biscuit Cutter with Handles: Norpro Biscuit/Cookie Cutters

If you really want to get a handle on baking biscuits, these ergonomic biscuit cutters by Norpro are a great option. The easy-grip plastic handles have rounded edges that are thicker and wider to give you more leverage. This will come in handy to reduce hand fatigue during your next baking marathon!

Crafted from sturdy stainless steel, these cutters ensure consistent results with every use and maintain their shape over time. Unfortunately, the plastic parts are not dishwasher-safe, so cleanup isn’t as easy. But the three sizes nestle neatly inside one another for compact storage, helping to keep your kitchen organized and clutter-free.

The Specs:

• Material: Stainless steel and plastic
• Number of Pieces: 3
• Dishwasher Safe: No

What I Like:

• Sturdy construction
• Nested design
• Comfortable grip

What I Don’t Like:

• Hand wash only

What Others Are Saying:

The Norpro Norpro Biscuit/Cookie Cutters have a 4.5-star rating from more than 1,300 ratings on Amazon. 

Buy the Norpro Biscuit/Cookie Cutters:

5. Best Double Sided Biscuit Cutter: SurgeHai Double Sided Biscuit Cutters

Welcome to the bonus round! This double-sided set of 6 biscuit cutters is more like a set of 12! Since each cutter has two sides, one that is fluted and one that has a plain edge, you can have double the fun in one compact tool. This design not only saves space in your kitchen but also offers flexibility in your baking projects. Whether you’re crafting small, bite-sized biscuits or larger, fluffier ones, this set has you covered without the need for multiple cutters cluttering your kitchen drawers.

The sharp edges of the cutters guarantee clean and precise cuts, resulting in beautifully shaped biscuits with every press. Plus, they provide a comfortable grip, making it effortless to maneuver through dough without straining your hands or wrists.

They’re made from stainless steel that offers reliability, longevity, and consistent performance. You can safely run them through the dishwasher before storing them on the metal ring that secures them together.

The Specs:

• Material: Stainless Steel
• Number of Pieces: 6 or 12
• Dishwasher Safe: Yes

What I Like:

• Each cutter has a fluted side and a plain side
• They nest to save space
• Sturdy
• Easy to grip
• Easy to clean

What I Don’t Like:

• Edges are sharp

What Others Are Saying:

The SurgeHai Double Sided Biscuit Cutters has a 4.7-star rating from more than 2,400 ratings on Amazon. 

Buy the SurgeHai Double Sided Biscuit Cutters:

6. Best for Dog Biscuits: Dog Bone Biscuit and Cookie Cutters

With so much energy geared toward pet health these days, you might be thinking about making homemade dog treats. This set of 5 classically shaped dog bone biscuit cutters is perfect for the job! No matter the size of your pup, you’re guaranteed to find a cutter to make the right-sized treat. 

You can’t wash them in the dishwasher, but there also aren’t any tricky corners for dough to get caught in, so cleaning them by hand is a quick job. Pair it with Meggan’s Homemade Peanut Butter to make a paw-some snack for your furry pal!

The Specs:

• Material: Alloy steel
• Number of Pieces: 5
• Dishwasher Safe: No

What I Like:

• Made in the USA
• Perfectly sized
• Sturdy construction

What I Don’t Like:

• Hand wash only

What Others Are Saying:

The Dog Bone and Biscuit Dog Treat Cookie Cutters has a 4.6-star rating from more than 2,900 ratings on Amazon. 

Buy the Dog Bone Biscuit and Cookie Cutters:

Other Biscuit Cutters to Consider

Williams Sonoma Olivewood Biscuit Cutter

Although this biscuit cutter from Williams Sonoma looks super pretty and rustic, the wood design also means you have to hand wash it and make sure it dries out before using it or putting it away. Occasionally, you also have to rub it with mineral oil to prevent it from drying out and cracking. In the end, a stainless steel set you can toss in the dishwasher seems much more practical since it requires much less maintenance. The Williams Sonoma Olivewood Biscuit Cutter is available at Williams Sonoma for $29.95.

OXO Good Grips Double-Sided Cookie & Biscuit Cutters

At first glance, you’d think these OXO biscuit cutters are great because they come in a plastic storage case that’s easy to store. But the drawback here is the fact that you’d have to make sure the cutters are completely dry before storing them in an airtight container, which could make cleanup take longer. The OXO Good Grips Double-Sided Cookie & Biscuit Cutters is available at Amazon for $16.29.

HULISEN 3 inch Biscuit Cutter

This biscuit cutter would be great for cranking out biscuits en masse, but storing this gadget would be a nightmare, unless you intend to use it weekly (which few would do). The HULISEN 3 inch Biscuit Cutter is available at Amazon for $7.99.

Why You Can Trust Us

Hi! I’m Belle, an award-winning content creator and an adjunct professor who works in restaurant PR in the Midwest. For more than 20 years, I’ve held almost every position imaginable in various restaurants, including ownership of a Korean-concept hot dog cart (that was named after my dog’s teeth). My writing and on-camera work can be seen on the Better Homes & Gardens and HGTV websites. 

To create this list of the very best biscuit cutters, I worked with Meggan to learn about which models she loves. Together, we discussed what qualities she appreciates most about them. I then hit the internet to research highly recommended models and read hundreds of online reviews to find the best of the best. From there, we compared them side by side and rated them on design, ease of use, and overall value to come up with our list of the best biscuit cutters.

Everything to Know Before Buying a Biscuit Cutter

What to Consider Before Buying a Biscuit Cutter

If you think your kitchen is in need of a quality biscuit cutter, there are a few things to consider when purchasing a set. 

Material: Biscuit cutters are typically made from stainless steel, plastic, or silicone. Stainless steel cutters are durable and provide clean cuts, while plastic and silicone cutters are flexible and less likely to cut your hands.

Size Range: Since there are so many practical uses for a biscuit cutter, the best biscuit cutters will come in a variety of sizes. Look for biscuit cutters that can be used for more than just cutting biscuits. Some cutters are designed to also cut cookies, scones, fondant, and fruit.

Shape: Consider the shape and size of biscuits you want to make. Round biscuit cutters are classic and versatile, while square or heart-shaped cutters can add a unique touch to your baked goods. Feel free to get creative!

Handle Design: Some biscuit cutters come with handles, which provide extra leverage and make it easier to press through thick dough. This is great for those with dexterity issues, but some people think the handle gets in the way. It all depends on personal preference! 

Storage: Consider the storage space you have available in your kitchen. Nested biscuit cutter sets or cutters with compact designs are ideal for saving space and keeping your kitchen organized. 

How Do You Make a Biscuit Cutter?

The easiest way to make a biscuit cutter at home is by repurposing common household items, like a recycled aluminum can into a makeshift cutter. 

To transform the can into a biscuit cutter, use scissors or a utility knife to carefully cut the can to your desired width. Make sure to check the edges of your homemade cutter for any rough spots or sharp edges that could cut your fingers. From there, you can use a file or sandpaper to smooth them out if necessary.

How Do You Cut Biscuits Without a Biscuit Cutter?

Cutting biscuits without a biscuit cutter may require a bit more effort and precision, but it can be done. 

All you need is a round object in your kitchen with a diameter similar to the size you want for your biscuits, like a drinking glass or a jar lid. If it’s sharp enough to cut through rolled out dough, press it firmly into the dough and twist slightly to cut out the biscuits. If you find that it doesn’t press through cleanly, use a knife or bench scraper to press straight down into the dough around it. 

How Big is a Biscuit Cutter?

Biscuit cutters come in various sizes to accommodate different preferences and recipes. The typical size of a biscuit cutter ranges from around 2 inches to 3 inches in diameter for standard-sized biscuits. 

However, biscuit cutters can be found in smaller or larger sizes, depending on the baking project. 

Pro tip: If you alter the size of your biscuits, don’t forget to also change their baking time so you don’t end up with a charred mess!

How Do You Use a Biscuit Cutter?

Once you’ve prepared the dough and rolled it out to your preferred thickness onto a floured surface, using a biscuit cutter to form your biscuits is a straightforward process.

1. Dip the edge of your cutter into flour to prevent sticking. 
2. Press the cutter straight down into the rolled-out dough, applying even pressure. 
3. Move the cutter back and forth slightly to ensure a clean cut. Avoid twisting. 
4. Repeat this process, cutting out as many biscuits as you can from the dough.

Here are a few pro tips to ensure your biscuits are uniform in size and shape:

• Choose a recipe that uses heavy cream. It provides the butter fat for tender biscuit dough but saves you the work of cutting butter into tiny, pea-sized pieces (plus the stress of keeping that butter cold enough throughout the mixing process).
• Keep the dough cold: Before cutting your biscuits, chill the biscuit cutter in the refrigerator for a few minutes. This helps prevent the dough from sticking to the cutter and ensures clean, sharp edges.
• Don’t twist: When cutting out the biscuits, press the cutter straight down into the dough without twisting. Twisting can tighten down the edges of the dough, preventing the biscuits from rising properly during baking.
• Flour is Your friend: Dip the edge of the biscuit cutter in flour before each cut to prevent sticking. This ensures clean cuts and helps release the biscuits from the cutter more easily.
• Use even pressure: Apply even pressure when pressing the biscuit cutter into the dough to ensure uniform biscuits. Press down firmly but gently to create clean cuts without squishing the dough.

The Best Biscuit Recipes

Are you ready to biscuit? Once you’ve purchased your new biscuit cutter, try these recipes out for your next brunch:

• 3-Ingredient Homemade Biscuits
• Biscuits and Gravy
• How to Make Biscuits
• Buttermilk Biscuits

Prices were accurate at time of publication.